October 28, 2015: The Amityville Horror Hoax - Joel Martin & Bill Birnes
Martin details how parapsychologist Stephen Kaplan spent 20 years investigating the fraud, systematically debunking each claim. The demon cat was a neighbor's pet, the oozing walls were fingerprint powder residue, the red room was chipping paint, and the green slime was leftover forensic chemicals. Weber later sued Lutz for his share after Lutz fled to the West Coast without paying. Martin also reveals the eerie personal toll, including learning of his wife's death by car just minutes before taping the Weber interview.
Bill Birnes then shares a stunning claim from a former intelligence officer: Father Malachi Martin, the famed Catholic scholar and exorcist, served as a cooperating individual for the CIA. According to this source, Martin retrieved an ancient artifact containing alien mathematical data from a Paris hotel room after the original finder was dispatched by an operative.
Key Moments
Art calls Amityville a hoax revelation: Art frames the episode as a duty to reveal whether the famous Amityville Horror story was a hoax.
Weber admits the fantasy: Martin says attorney William Weber and George Lutz created the fantasy and Weber admitted it on the radio.
Hoax over champagne: Martin says the story was created over bottles of champagne or wine.
The red room was paint: Martin says the famous red room was just chipping paint, not blood.
Green slime was forensic residue: Martin explains the alleged green slime as leftover police forensic material backing up in the toilet.
Books by These Guests
Selected titles from the guest bibliography. Use them as context for this appearance, not required listening.
Continue exploring
Paths out of this episode
A stronger next move anchored to this specific broadcast.